Start Spreading the News.

Authentic New York-style bagels, stacked into sandwiches worth waking up for — right here in Orange Park.

What makes our bagels special?

The real deal, no compromises...

Real NY bagels, real deli flavor, real generous portions — no shortcuts, no filler.

Park Avenue NY Bagels brings you authentic New York-style bagels with that signature chewy crust and soft, pillowy inside.

Our breakfast sandwiches are made fresh to order with quality ingredients and genuine care in every bite. As a family-owned shop right here in Orange Park, we treat every customer like they just walked into our kitchen. Good food, good people, and a breakfast worth waking up for — that's what we're all about.

New! Chicken BLT

Perfectly breaded chicken strips, topped with cheese, bacon, lettuce, tomato and mayo in your choice of bread.

Every bite delivers that satisfying crunch from the chicken, balanced by melty cheese and smoky, crispy bacon. Fresh lettuce and tomato add a cool, crisp finish, while our mayo ties it all together with the perfect creamy touch. It's a hearty, flavor-packed sandwich built for anyone craving something filling and delicious. Pair it with your favorite bread to make it exactly the way you like it.

Order it today!

A picture can only say so much

Take a closer look at what we serve up every day at Park Avenue NY Bagels. From classic bagels and deli sandwiches to breakfast favorites, every item is made with real ingredients and genuine care. Browse our gallery below to see (and crave) what's waiting for you.

Breakfast or brunch

Enjoy a fantastic breakfast or brunch at out shop or at home! Whether you're stopping in for a quick bite before work or settling in for a relaxed weekend brunch with family, we've got something to satisfy every craving. From classic bagels to hearty deli sandwiches, our menu is made to fit however you like to start your day.

See menu

Not just bagels...

A breakfast or brunch is not complete without a great drink!

Warm up with a classic coffee or cool down with our iced coffee favorites, including cold brew, caramel macchiato, mocha iced coffee, and vanilla iced coffee.

Craving something fresh? Try our freshly squeezed orange juice, or choose from other delicious flavors like mango, strawberry, passion fruit, guava, and lulo. And of course, we've got your favorite Coca-Cola products on hand too.

Whatever you're in the mood for, we've got the perfect drink to complete your meal.

See menu

Featured in Clayton News!

All you need is a little spread, community (Article)

ORANGE PARK - It's true that there's a Park Avenue in Orange Park and New York City. One is known for its hustle and bustle. The other is surrounded by a soft-pace lifestyle. Read more

Orange Park bagel shop spreads cream cheese, connection

ORANGE PARK -Start spreading the news: Park Avenue NY Bagels, located at 1177 Park Ave., is open and ready to bring authentic flavor from New York to their new local business in Orange Park. The …Read more